By|Board of Directors

Directors of community associations, like directors of other nonprofit corporations, are not guarantors of the success of the association and are not typically liable for mere mistakes in judgment. Courts require only that directors act as ordinary, prudent people and do not hold them to a standard of prudent business people. They recognize that directors must sometimes make difficult cost-benefit decisions and will not generally second-guess those decisions as long as the directors acted in good faith, and in a manner they believed to be in the best interests of the association, and as reasonably prudent people.

Duty of Ordinary Care

The directors of a homeowners association are held to a duty to exercise ordinary care in their actions as directors, and are further obligated to avoid self-dealing and conflicts of interest. Examples of cases where a director breaches his or her duty of care might include mismanagement of association funds, failure to enforce the governing documents, and failure to maintain the associations premises. A determination of whether or not a director has exercised ordinary care in his or her actions necessitates consideration of the following three factors:

  • Was the act performed in good faith;
  • Was the act performed in a manner that the director believed to be in the best interests of the association; and
  • Was the act performed with such care as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use in similar circumstances, including reasonable inquiry.

If a volunteer director satisfies the above elements, he or she should not be subject to liability for damages arising out of their conduct by virtue of the business judgment rule. However, directors could lose the protection of the business judgment rule by delegating too many duties. Although directors are generally authorized by state statutes and/or the associations bylaws to delegate certain management responsibilities to another person, management company or a committee, the ultimate responsibility for the management of the homeowners association still rests with the board of directors. Another exception to the general rule where a director could have potential exposure to liability is a situation where he or she, in seeking election to the board, may have represented that they have special expertise such as an attorney, architect, or accountant. Such a director could conceivably be held to a higher standard of care on the basis of their representations.

A directors corporate duty of ordinary care is typically created by state statutes and is owed to the associations members and not to third parties or other members of the public. Thus, a director may generally be held liable to a third party under common law theories of negligence for breaches of their common law duty to exercise ordinary care when he or she has engaged in tortuous conduct that has caused injuries to a third person. Such liability is independent of whether the director was acting on behalf of the association, which may also be exposed to liability as a result of the directors actions.

Doctrine of Judicial Deference

By|Board of Directors

Directors of community associations, like directors of other nonprofit corporations, are not guarantors of the success of the association and are not typically liable for mere mistakes in judgment. Courts require only that directors act as ordinary, prudent people and do not hold them to a standard of prudent business people. They recognize that directors must sometimes make difficult cost-benefit decisions and will not generally second-guess those decisions as long as the directors acted in good faith, and in a manner they believed to be in the best interests of the association, and as reasonably prudent people.

Duty of Ordinary Care

The directors of a homeowners association are held to a duty to exercise ordinary care in their actions as directors, and are further obligated to avoid self-dealing and conflicts of interest. Examples of cases where a director breaches his or her duty of care might include mismanagement of association funds, failure to enforce the governing documents, and failure to maintain the associations premises. A determination of whether or not a director has exercised ordinary care in his or her actions necessitates consideration of the following three factors:

  • Was the act performed in good faith;
  • Was the act performed in a manner that the director believed to be in the best interests of the association; and
  • Was the act performed with such care as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use in similar circumstances, including reasonable inquiry.

If a volunteer director satisfies the above elements, he or she should not be subject to liability for damages arising out of their conduct by virtue of the business judgment rule. However, directors could lose the protection of the business judgment rule by delegating too many duties. Although directors are generally authorized by state statutes and/or the associations bylaws to delegate certain management responsibilities to another person, management company or a committee, the ultimate responsibility for the management of the homeowners association still rests with the board of directors. Another exception to the general rule where a director could have potential exposure to liability is a situation where he or she, in seeking election to the board, may have represented that they have special expertise such as an attorney, architect, or accountant. Such a director could conceivably be held to a higher standard of care on the basis of their representations.

A directors corporate duty of ordinary care is typically created by state statutes and is owed to the associations members and not to third parties or other members of the public. Thus, a director may generally be held liable to a third party under common law theories of negligence for breaches of their common law duty to exercise ordinary care when he or she has engaged in tortuous conduct that has caused injuries to a third person. Such liability is independent of whether the director was acting on behalf of the association, which may also be exposed to liability as a result of the directors actions.

Doctrine of Judicial Deference

Over 2000 HOA board members and management staff use our services every day to enhance their HOA experience. Now you can too with a three month membership – completely FREE.

what is HOA Member Services?

All the tools you need to run your HOA

We provide valuable information, resources, and education to members and management personnel of homeowners associations in a fast and efficient manner to educate and assist them in connection with the handling of issues they are confronted with and in the management and operation of their homeowners association.

-Larry Szabo, President

A subscription with HOA Member Services will provide you with valuable information, resources, and education to enhance your HOA experience

Articles & Case Decisions

Resources

Monthly HOA Newsletter

Subscriber Only Mailings

Free Copy of HOA LIVING

25% OFF Download Forms

1 User

Articles & Case Decisions

Resources

Monthly HOA Newsletter

Subscriber Only Mailings

Free Copy of HOA LIVING

25% OFF Download Forms

1 User

Articles & Case Decisions

Resources

Monthly HOA Newsletter

Subscriber Only Mailings

Free Copy of HOA LIVING

Free Unlimited Download Forms

Personal Support

1 User

Articles & Case Decisions

Resources

Monthly HOA Newsletter

Subscriber Only Mailings

Free Copy of HOA LIVING

Free Unlimited Download Forms

Personal Support

Up to 10 Users

Ready to get started? Select a Subscription Plan Below

 

[easy-pricing-toggle default_pricing_table_id=”136819″ default_title=”Personal Plan Yearly” default_subtitle=”Pay yearly and Save ~20%” alternate_title=”Personal Plan Monthly” alternate_subtitle=”$5 mo or $48 yr ~20% OFF” alternate_pricing_table_id=”136857″ font_color=”#000000″ background_color=”#8dc63f” border_color=”#8dc63f” ]

90-Day Free Trial

Over 2000 HOA board members and management staff use our services every day to enhance their HOA experience. Now you can too with a three month membership – completely FREE.

what is HOA Member Services?

All the tools you need to run your HOA

We provide valuable information, resources, and education to members and management personnel of homeowners associations in a fast and efficient manner to educate and assist them in connection with the handling of issues they are confronted with and in the management and operation of their homeowners association.

-Larry Szabo, President

Products & Services

What You Get

Access our HOA State Resources and link directly to your 2019 HOA Statutes, helpful state links, licenses and statuses of service providers, and our trusted HOA affiliates

Browse our library of over 175 operational HOA Forms that are easy to download as well as our library of educational How-To Guides and HOA Condensed State Statutes

An extremely helpful collection of step-by-step guides that provide direction on how to handle various matters that are commonly encountered by members and managers of homeowners associations

Stay up to date with legislative trends. We cover a wide variety of important HOA Topics and keep our subscribers informed with over 475 (and counting) published HOA Featured Articles and Case Decisions

ABOUT THE TRIAL

What are you signing up for?

This offer is a completely FREE three month subscription to our “Personal Plan” which includes these Subscriber Only benefits:

  • Access to all Articles and Case Decisions
  • Monthly HOA Newsletter – You’ll get the latest case decisions right to your inbox
  • Subscriber Only Emails
  • Free copy of HOA Living – all you need to know about how an HOA operates
  • 25% off all downloadable HOA Forms

 

Pricing

No Credit Card Required

This trial is completely free, you are under no obligation to continue your subscription. We feel strongly that youll agree our product is an invaluable asset to your entire homeowners association.

When you click the button below the 90-day Free Trial will be added to your cart and you’ll be brought to our checkout page. You’ll create your account, check out and start taking advantage of the benefits – ALL FOR FREE